by Barbara Loe Fisher
It was 1977 when I found out I was going to become a Mom. I instinctively knew I needed to be careful while I was pregnant, especially during the first two trimesters when the major organ systems of the fetus develop at a rapid rate. In the 1960’s there had been a lot of publicity about babies dying or being born without arms or legs because women had taken a drug (Thalidomide) for morning sickness in the first or second trimester of pregnancy1 and I wanted to make sure I did everything I could to protect my health and the health of my baby before and after he was born.
Related Articles
Mothers to be in my generation were told to take extra vitamins and
eat nutritious food but, most of all, to avoid anything that could harm
the developing fetus like alcohol, cigarette smoke, medications,
radiation, household cleaning products and other toxic exposures. Some
of us were aware of the risks of heavy anesthesia during delivery and
signed up for Lamaze classes to prepare for a drug-free birth, which
many obstetricians discouraged, and we chose to breastfeed, even though a
lot of pediatricians were pushing formula and bottles back then.
Today, pregnant women face a different set of difficult questions
and choices about keeping themselves and their babies healthy. Among
them are whether or not to get vaccinations during pregnancy that public
health officials, obstetricians and pediatricians say will protect
pregnant women and their newborns from getting sick with influenza and
B. pertussis whooping cough.
Toxic Exposures & Assumption of Safety - Is It A Good Idea?
Although since the 1970’s public health officials have recommended
influenza vaccinations for pregnant women in the second or third
trimester,2 relatively
few obstetricians promoted the vaccine until the past decade when, in
2006, the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) strengthened recommendations
that all pregnant women, healthy or not, should get a flu shot in any
trimester.3 Then, in 2011, a pertussis containing Tdap shot was recommended for all pregnant women, preferably after 20 weeks gestation.4 Both current vaccine recommendations5 6 7 are endorsed by the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG)8 9 the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) and other medical trade associations.10 11
With these recommendations, the time-honored rule of avoiding any
potential toxic exposure that might interfere with the normal
development of the fetus has been suspended and replaced with an
assumption that vaccination during pregnancy is safe. But what is the
scientific evidence documenting that this assumption is a well-informed
one?
Glaring Lack of Safety Testing
You have to look no further than information in the vaccine
manufacturer product inserts and posted online by the U.S. Food and Drug
Administration (FDA) and Centers for Disease Control (CDC) to quickly
answer that question.
FACT: Drug companies did not test the safety and effectiveness of giving influenza or Tdap vaccine to pregnant women before the vaccines were licensed in the U.S.12 13 and there is almost no data on inflammatory or other biological responses to these vaccines that could affect pregnancy and birth outcomes.14
FACT: The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) lists influenza and Tdap vaccines as either Pregnancy Category B or C biologicals15 which means that adequate testing has not been done in humans to demonstrate safety for pregnant women and it is not known whether the vaccines can cause fetal harm or affect reproduction capacity. The manufacturers of influenza and Tdap vaccines state that human toxicity and fertility studies are inadequate and warn that the influenza and Tdap vaccines should “be given to a pregnant woman only if clearly needed.”16 17 18
FACT: There are ingredients in influenza and pertussis containing Tdap vaccines that have not been fully evaluated for potential genotoxic19 or other adverse effects on the human fetus developing in the womb that may negatively affect health after birth, including aluminum adjuvants, mercury containing (Thimerosal) preservatives and many more bioactive and potentially toxic ingredients.20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29
FACT: There are serious problems with outdated testing procedures for determining the potency and toxicity of pertussis vaccines and some scientists are calling for limits to be established for specific toxin content of pertussis-containing vaccines.30
FACT: There are no published biological mechanism studies that assess pre-vaccination health status and measure changes in brain and immune function and chromosomal integrity after vaccination of pregnant women or their babies developing in the womb.31
FACT: Since licensure of influenza and Tdap vaccines in the U.S., there have been no well designed prospective case controlled studies comparing the health outcomes of large groups of women who get influenza and pertussis containing Tdap vaccines during pregnancy either separately or simultaneously compared to those who do not get the vaccines, and no similar health outcome comparisons of their newborns at birth or in the first year of life have been conducted. Safety and effectiveness evaluations that have been conducted are either small,32 retrospective,33 34 compare vaccinated women to vaccinated women35 or have been performed by drug company or government health officials using unpublished data.36
FACT: The FDA has licensed Tdap vaccines to be given once as a single dose pertussis booster shot to individuals over 10 or 11 years old. The CDC’s recommendation that doctors give every pregnant woman a Tdap vaccination during every pregnancy - regardless of whether a woman has already received one dose of Tdap - is an off-label use of the vaccine.37
FACT: Injuries and deaths from pertussis-containing vaccines are the most compensated claims in the federal Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (VICP) and influenza vaccine injuries and deaths are the second most compensated claim.38
FACT: A 2013 published study evaluating reports of acute disseminated encephalomyelitis (ADEM) following vaccination in the U. S. Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) and in a European vaccine reaction reporting system found that seasonal influenza vaccine was the most frequently suspected cause of brain inflammation after 18 years old, representing 32 percent of the total cases reported, and pertussis containing DTaP was among the vaccines most frequently associated with brain inflammation in children between birth and age five.39
FACT: When a pregnant woman is harmed by an influenza or Tdap vaccine, drug companies selling the vaccines in the U.S., doctors and other vaccine providers are shielded from vaccine injury lawsuits40 but it is unclear whether vaccine injuries sustained by an unborn child in the womb will qualify for federal vaccine injury compensation.41
Rush to Vaccinate: Policy Preceding Science
In addition to lack of credible scientific evidence to demonstrate safety,42 43 there is not enough credible epidemiological and biological mechanism evidence to demonstrate it is effective or necessary 44 45 46 47 for every pregnant woman to get an influenza and Tdap shot during every pregnancy. The rush to vaccinate pregnant women and reach into the womb to try to passively vaccinate the developing fetus48 49 is a clear case of policy preceding science.
An experimental genetically engineered nanoparticle vaccine for respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) and another one for Group B Streptococcus are in advanced clinical trials and reportedly likely will be exclusively recommended for pregnant women after they are licensed.50 With new vaccines on the horizon that will target pregnant women, it is critically important that more bad vaccine policy does not precede good vaccine science.
Pregnant women today need to take a long, hard look at the well advertised but theoretical benefits and unknown risks of getting vaccinated during pregnancy before making a vaccine decision. It is especially important when there are so many warning signs that America’s highly vaccinated child and adult population in the 21st century is not very healthy.
Maternal and infant mortality statistics are a classic measure of a
nation’s public health status and, in this country, here are red flags
that cannot be ignored any longer.
Maternal and Infant Mortality Rates High in America
How many young couples of child bearing age know that women getting
pregnant and delivering babies in America today have more than twice the risk of dying during pregnancy, childbirth or after giving birth than they did three decades ago?51 52 Women
having babies are dying of heart failure, high blood pressure and
stroke, infection of the blood, diabetes and blood clots in greater
numbers because the maternal death rate in America has been climbing
since 1987.53 We
now rank a dismal number 50 in maternal mortality in the world, which
is worse than that of most European countries and some countries in Asia
and the Middle East.54
Equally shocking is the fact that the U.S. now has the highest first day infant death rate of all industrialized countries55 and ranks number 31 among nations in infant mortality.56 Preterm birth rates have increased 36% since the early 1980’s57 and 6 out of every 1,000 babies born alive in America die before their first birthday.58
Birth defects, chromosomal damage, premature birth, low birth
weight and sudden infant death syndrome are the leading causes of death
for about 23,000 newborn infants every year,59 with
half of those deaths occurring on the first day of life. A baby born in
America is twice as likely to die within the first 24 hours as babies
born in the European Union.60
Why Is Health in the U.S. on Such A Steep Decline?
U.S. public health officials say there are “no clear” answers for why our maternal mortality rate is skyrocketing.61 They
don’t know why so many of our babies are dying on the first day and
within the first year of life, in stark contrast to many other nations
where maternal and infant mortality rates are declining.
Public health officials also can’t figure out why so many infants
and children in America are plagued with brain and immune system
problems. The unprecedented, unexplained chronic disease and disability
epidemic 62 has gotten worse in the past three decades – with 1 child in 6 now learning disabled; 63 1 in 9 suffering with asthma;64 1 in 50 developing autism;65 1 in 400 becoming diabetic66 and millions more suffering with severe food allergies,67 inflammatory bowel disease 68 and other chronic illness.69 70
The health of American adults has also deteriorated during the past
three decades compared to other wealthy nations where health is
improving71 and our life expectancy is worse than many other countries as well.72 The
CDC says that today chronic diseases are the most common and costly
causes of death and disability with about half of all adults living with
at least one chronic illness.73
U.S. Number One Market for Drugs & Vaccines
What is not on the list of potential causes for this
failing public health report card is lack of access to drugs and
vaccines. With a population of 316 million people out of 7 billion
people on the earth, the U.S. spends nearly $3 trillion dollars per year
on health care74 - more than any other nation in the world75 76 - and we consume 40 percent of all drugs sold globally.77 78 79 In addition, America is the leading purchaser of vaccines in the world’s $32 billion dollar vaccine market.80 81 82
Since 1981, 95 percent of all children entering kindergarten have
received multiple doses of seven vaccines including pertussis and
measles vaccines.83 In 1991, the CDC recommended all infants get a hepatitis B shot at 12 hours old84 and,
by 2012, more than 70 percent of all newborns had received a hepatitis B
shot at birth while between 80 and 90 percent of three year olds had
gotten multiple doses of eleven vaccines.85
In a crusade to eliminate an expanding list of microbes, U.S.
health officials currently direct pediatricians to give children 49
doses of 14 vaccines by age six starting on the day of birth with more
than two dozen doses administered by an infant’s first birthday.86 More
than two dozen additional vaccinations are recommended or mandated for
teenagers and adults, including annual flu shots throughout life.87
Has Mandated Use of More Vaccines Compromised America’s Health?
Every state in the U.S. has laws requiring dozens of vaccinations for daycare and school attendance88 in
contrast to neighboring Mexico and Canada, which recommend but do not
mandate vaccines (a provision in Canada’s Constitution prohibits
compulsory vaccination).89
Japan, New Zealand, Australia, Iceland and Norway recommend but do not legally require vaccines and 15 countries in the European Union, including United Kingdom, Germany, Spain, Greece, Denmark, Netherlands, Finland and Austria similarly recommend but do not mandate vaccines.90 All of these countries have lower infant mortality rates than the U.S. and do not recommend that infants under one year old get as many vaccines as American infants do.91 In fact, no other country legally requires92 the numbers of vaccinations that the U.S. does for children to attend daycare and school or for adults to keep their jobs.93
Japan, New Zealand, Australia, Iceland and Norway recommend but do not legally require vaccines and 15 countries in the European Union, including United Kingdom, Germany, Spain, Greece, Denmark, Netherlands, Finland and Austria similarly recommend but do not mandate vaccines.90 All of these countries have lower infant mortality rates than the U.S. and do not recommend that infants under one year old get as many vaccines as American infants do.91 In fact, no other country legally requires92 the numbers of vaccinations that the U.S. does for children to attend daycare and school or for adults to keep their jobs.93
It is no wonder that more Americans are asking questions about why
our children need so many vaccines and why adults need to get a flu shot
every year – even during pregnancy – when our population is already the
most vaccinated in the world but far less healthy than other countries
that do not mandate or recommend so many vaccines.
Ask for the Science
If you are pregnant and have other children, be aware that the
American Academy of Pediatrics is urging pediatricians to vaccinate
parents bringing their children in for sick or well baby visits,
especially pregnant women.94 If
an obstetrician or pediatrician pressures you to get vaccinated while
you are pregnant, ask the doctor to show you the science. If you
conclude the vaccine’s benefits do not outweigh the risks for you and
your baby but are threatened or sanctioned in any way for making an
informed choice, you should find another doctor who will treat you with
respect and honor your health care choices.
Go to NVIC.org to learn more and sign up for NVIC’s free online
Advocacy Portal so you can work to protect the freedom to make voluntary
vaccine decisions in your state.
It’s your health, your family, your choice.
Reading all the facts Barbara really scares me. I had my three children in the 80's and thank goodness all are healthy and healthy to this day. We are Canadian and never pressured for vaccines back then. Now my two grandchildren are in the public school system (Canadian) and my daughter received a letter from our school board saying her youngest (grade 1 now) has to have vaccines that her son (grade 2) didn't have to have or she can't attend school.
ReplyDeleteWe were shocked, my little grand daughter isn't usually the healthiest, always has a cold, always has breathing issues, that doctor keeps saying she will grow out of. So anyways, she hasn't been healthy enough to get the required vaccine and if she doesn't she will have to forfeit school. Which is confusing, because if she doesn't go to school than mom is in trouble. But she can't have the vaccine, because she isn't healthy enough, but she is healthy enough to attend school - like I said just really a cold or breathing. What is a grand mother to do, let alone what does a mother do. And since when does Canadian kids have to have shots to go to school?